First I tried booting our navigator off the ship. A real drunkard, that one. Not a man was sad to see him go. But it did no good. We were back at the same port three days later.
I told the new navigator, Barnoff was his name, to keep us going due south for a fortnight. Even kept a spyglass on the coastline, making me right certain we were moving on to fresh seas. But when at last we cut our sales and made for port my glass fogged over with a dank, clinging mist. We had returned to Mosquito Bay.
After I drowned the third navigator with my bare hands, I realized it had to be the sails that were setting us off course. Somehow I was the only one who saw our masts needed replacing. Nor did any man understand why I sank my original ship outright and commandeered a Spanish vessel. Oh, the gold I have spent on new systems of navigation! How many complex tools and mystical totems have I thrown overboard, now littering the bottom of the bay?
Eighteen years of this. I have stretched every excursion on the open ocean longer than the last, until even me first mate is on the edge of mutiny. When I finally tell the crew, sun-crazed and starving, to sail us with the wind to the nearest port on the map, they cheer with voices of resentful relief. Then they make sail, while I rot in my chamber, and head right back to Mosquito Bay.
Curse this port. Curse every inch of the Silver Peninsula, which seem to stretch in every direction on the compass. Curse the whole world if this is all there is left of it. Wish not that I had ever set sail were I to know where I would end up.
On every return I pitch more of the men off the boat and search for new crewmates who go about their hollow lives in the town of Sandfly. I’ve taken young boys, women even, to fill the ranks with some faces I haven’t seen buried at sea a dozen times over. It’s usually the armada that gets them, five months out. Three months in we capture a carrack loaded with silk heading North (or is it West?) that surrenders without a shot fired. On our way to offload the goods we hit the fleet. It matters not which current or wind we follow; on the first day of the fifth month the cannons roar.
Some years we make chase, try to stay ahead of the gunships, hide in archipelagos until at last they lose interest in a single band of pirates. Not anymore, though. Aye, the thrill of the hunt is long gone for this fox. Yet, the alternative has no spice to it either, of course. If we let them catch us, or even charge them guns blazing, they somehow manage to sink themselves in the crossfire. There we sit, the last ship among timbers and ash, men struck dumb by the fortune that let them survive such an encounter. Nay, all the vinegar has drained even from victory.
The years bleed together in my memory now, but there was one such encounter I will never forget, nor will I ever try again. When I heard the cry from the crow’s nest, warning us of the ship on the horizon, I lit a long fuse leading to our gunpowder stores. I deployed a landing boat and rowed towards the armada alone, abandoning my ship and its doomed crew. It warmed my soul to hear those men scream in pain instead of cheers of victory.
When the ships finally made it to the sight of the wreck they took me aboard as prisoner, just as planned. The soldiers could not decide whether to curse or commend my murderous betrayal. They led me to their captain’s chambers to let him decide whether I was to be kept or hanged on the spot. That’s when they discovered the man was gone and a boat was missing. They spotted him some two-hundred yards windward. The distraction allowed me to break free and rush underdeck, seeking the powder keg. And I found it, fuse but an inch left, a mutiny upon this vessel as well. Yet I couldn’t find it in me to put out the flame, even in the seconds as it neared the powder. Perhaps it was exhaustion that stopped me. Aye, mayhaps it was curiosity, after all those years, that stayed my hand. So I let it light the keg.
But, of course, the devil would not release me. As the fuse met the wood it flared, then suffocated, falling to the ground, harmless. I found the crew, my captors, amidship watching fires in the distance. Despite sinking my own ship, there was the armada in flames at its own hand as well.
None paid me heed as I took to their mast, clambering to the crow’s nest, certain I would spy the coast of Mosquito Bay, in silhouette beyond the smoking fleet. Instead I saw, in the near-distance, rowboats with one-man crews. Through a glass I spied captains, one for each ship, each striking off in his own direction, barely taking care to dodge the flotsam of neighboring wrecks.
Hours passed as my captors watched these sad figures disappear over every horizon. Eventually they convened, each uncertain of their orders now that every captain had abandoned them. Well, not every captain. At first they would not follow my orders, but they agreed with my suggestion: sail with the wind, land at the first port with soft beds and warm women. In time, I told them, those boatmen would be forgotten. Those lonely ghosts would fade from memory.
Aye, it were lies I told. Lies that returned me to shore once again, where time would only burn that day into my mind. For eternity, I am besought by the image of a hundred men alone, together. I have been given just one small mercy: I could not discern the their faces, my old eyes poisoned by sun, salt, and smoke. But I am sure someday I will see each of them board my ship in the port of Mosquito Bay.